Are Spam Texts Still Covered by the TCPA? The 2026 Court Split Explained
In July 2026 the Seventh Circuit ruled that consumers cannot sue over texts under the TCPA Do-Not-Call provision. The Ninth Circuit reads the law differently. Here is what the split means for spam-text claims and which options remain.
Are Spam Texts Still Covered by the TCPA?
For more than twenty years, courts treated a text message as a "call" under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA), largely because the Federal Communications Commission said so in 2003. That assumption is now being tested. In 2026, two federal appeals courts read the word "call" in opposite ways, and where you live may affect which claims you can bring over unwanted texts.
Why This Question Reopened
In 2025, the U.S. Supreme Court decided McLaughlin Chiropractic Associates v. McKesson Corp. and held that federal trial courts are not bound by the FCC's interpretations of the TCPA. Courts must read the statute for themselves. Since then, defendants in text-message cases have argued that the statute's words do not reach texts at all.
The Seventh Circuit: No Do-Not-Call Lawsuit for Texts
On July 14, 2026, the Seventh Circuit decided Steidinger v. Blackstone Medical Services. The plaintiffs said they received marketing texts promoting home sleep tests and that the texts continued after they opted out or registered on the National Do Not Call Registry.
A unanimous panel ruled against them. The court focused on section 227(c)(5) of the TCPA, which lets a person sue after receiving more than one "telephone call" in a 12-month period in violation of the Do-Not-Call rules. Its reasoning:
- In 1991, when the TCPA was passed, a "telephone call" meant communication by sound. A text does not reproduce sound.
- Elsewhere the statute uses the broader phrase "telephone call or message." Congress chose the narrower words for the right to sue.
- The FCC's view that Do-Not-Call protections cover texts was issued under a different subsection and does not control who may sue.
- Congress amended another part of the TCPA in 2018 to mention text messages expressly, and did not do the same here.
The Ninth Circuit: A Text Is a Call
On January 13, 2026, the Ninth Circuit decided Howard v. Republican National Committee. That case involved a different part of the TCPA, section 227(b), which restricts autodialed and prerecorded calls to cell phones.
The Ninth Circuit said a "call" is an attempt to communicate by telephone and that text messaging plainly fits that definition. The court stressed that it reached this conclusion from the statute's own language, not from deference to the FCC. The plaintiff still lost, for a separate reason: the prerecorded voice was inside a video that only played if the recipient pressed play.
How the Two Rulings Fit Together
The two cases interpret different subsections, so they do not directly overrule each other:
- Section 227(c)(5) covers Do-Not-Call violations. The Seventh Circuit says texts are not included.
- Section 227(b) covers autodialed and prerecorded calls. The Ninth Circuit says texts are included, and the Seventh Circuit noted that earlier decisions treating texts as calls arose under this section.
What This Means If You Are Getting Spam Texts
A ruling against one legal theory is not a ruling that spam texts are legal. Several paths remain:
- Autodialer and prerecorded-message claims. Claims under section 227(b) were not decided by the Seventh Circuit.
- State laws. Many state telemarketing laws name text messages expressly, including laws in Florida, Texas, and Virginia. These are becoming more important as the federal picture shifts.
- Courts outside the Seventh Circuit. The Steidinger ruling binds only federal courts in Illinois, Indiana, and Wisconsin.
- Voice calls. Nothing in these rulings changes Do-Not-Call claims based on actual phone calls. If the same company both called and texted you, the calls still count.
- Government enforcement. The FCC's rules extending Do-Not-Call protection to texts remain in effect, and the FCC can still enforce them.
What To Do Now
- Keep documenting. Screenshot every text with its date, time, and sender number. Evidence you save today is useful whichever way the law settles.
- Log calls separately. Note any voice calls, voicemails, or ringless voicemails from the same sender.
- Opt out and save proof. Reply STOP and screenshot it. Messages after an opt-out matter under several federal and state rules.
- Note your state. Where you live and where you received the messages can determine which laws apply.
- Do not wait on the Supreme Court. Filing deadlines keep running while the courts sort this out. TCPA claims generally must be brought within four years.
Frequently Asked Questions
I live in Illinois, Indiana, or Wisconsin. Is my spam-text case over? Not necessarily. The ruling removes one federal theory, the private Do-Not-Call claim for texts. Other federal theories and any state-law claims need to be evaluated separately by an attorney.
Does this affect robocalls? No. Both decisions concern text messages. Voice calls and prerecorded messages remain covered as before.
Could this change again? Yes. Other appeals courts may weigh in, the Supreme Court may take up the question, and Congress could amend the statute.
Sources
- Steidinger v. Blackstone Medical Services, No. 25-2398 (7th Cir. July 14, 2026)
- Howard v. Republican National Committee, 164 F.4th 1119 (9th Cir. January 13, 2026)
- McLaughlin Chiropractic Associates, Inc. v. McKesson Corp. (U.S. Supreme Court, 2025)
- 47 U.S.C. 227(a)(4), 227(b), and 227(c)(5)
- Troutman Pepper Locke, "Seventh Circuit Rules Text Messages Are Not Telephone Calls Under TCPA 227(c)(5)" (July 15, 2026)
About This Article
Last reviewed: November 11, 2026. This article is general information, not legal advice. The rules described here are changing quickly and can apply differently depending on where you live and what you received. An attorney can tell you how they apply to your situation.
Think You Have a Case?
Based on what you just read, if you experienced violations, submit a free case. A contingency attorney will evaluate your situation.