The Lead Generator Loophole and What the TCPA Does to Protect You
You filled out one form, and suddenly dozens of companies you never heard of started calling. That's the lead generator loophole. Here's how it works and what the TCPA still does to protect you.
When was the last time you got a call or text from a company you'd never heard of and had never authorized? Chances are good it was pretty recently. Spam calls and texts have exploded, with billions being sent every month. You've probably experienced the lead generator loophole firsthand.
What Is the Lead Generator Loophole?
When you visit a website, you'll often see a wall of fine print at the bottom of the page. Buried in that is phrasing that says by submitting your information, you're consenting to be contacted by a list of "partners" or "network members." That might include dozens or even hundreds of businesses you've never heard of and didn't specifically choose to hear from. This is the "lead generator loophole."
What the FCC Tried to Do
The FCC created a rule to close this loophole. The idea was that consent had to be obtained one company at a time, rather than giving blanket permission. The rule also included a "logically and topically associated" requirement, which meant that calls and texts had to be related to whatever you were actually shopping for when you gave consent.
The Rule That Never Materialized
Just three days before the rule was to go into effect, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit vacated it entirely in Insurance Marketing Coalition Limited v. FCC. The court held that the FCC's one-to-one rule went beyond what "prior express consent" actually means.
Where Do Consumers Stand?
The lead generator loophole is still open. Lead generators can still use a single broad consent disclosure to pass your contact information to multiple sellers, as long as the consent meets the existing "clear and conspicuous" standard. However, the TCPA still protects you.
The TCPA Is Still Very Much in Force
Even without the one-to-one rule, the TCPA still offers substantial protection:
- Consent has to be "real and documented."
- The Do Not Call Registry still applies.
- Revocation of consent is your right.
- Statutory damages are available.
What You Can Do If You're Still Getting Unwanted Calls
If you've been receiving calls or texts you didn't agree to, or if you've asked to stop receiving them and they keep coming, it's worth connecting with an attorney and finding out.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the FCC's one-to-one consent rule currently in effect?
No, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit vacated it three days before it was scheduled to take effect.
Does the court decision mean companies can call me without my consent?
No, the TCPA still requires prior express consent before companies can contact you using automated dialing systems or prerecorded messages.
Can I still file a TCPA claim if I'm receiving unwanted calls?
Potentially, yes. The TCPA still provides statutory damages for violations, and the existing rules around consent, Do Not Call protections, and revocation of consent are fully intact.
What if I asked a company to stop contacting me, but they keep calling?
That's probably a violation. Under FCC rules, businesses have to honor consent revocation through any reasonable means and process your opt-out within 10 business days.
Think You Have a Case?
Submit your spam case free. Contingency attorneys only get paid if you win.